An employee policy guide can describe company programs and benefits and communicate general information about the organization. Many employers also include disclaimers to make it clear that the policy guide does not create unintended obligations.
Employer Seeks to Keep Policy guide From Getting Out of Hand
“Your policy guide says we are entitled to short-term disability benefits,” said employee Veronica Dale. “I didn’t make it up; it’s your own promise to employees like me who need these benefits.”
“If you read it, it’s clear that the policy guide is informational, not a contract, and that we have the right to change provisions in the policy guide at any time,” countered HR director Sidney Petit.
Is the policy guide a contract?
Facts: A large computer services provider hired a customer service representative in 2002, and provided her with a policy guide that included a section describing its policy on short-term disability benefits.
She applied for benefits at various times because she suffered from migraine headaches and laryngitis, and she underwent two surgeries. Although some of her requests for benefits were granted, many were denied for lack of supporting medical documentation and because the employer’s outside administrator concluded that the employee was not disabled. She filed a lawsuit against the employer alleging breach of contract.
According to the court, following the introductory paragraph in the policy guide, there was a disclaimer set off by a bold heading. The disclaimer stated that the procedures in the policy guide should not be interpreted as altering the at-will employment relationship and did not constitute an employment contract. Another disclaimer in the policy guide said the employer retained the right to change, modify, suspend, interpret, or eliminate any provision of the policy guide at any time, the court noted.
Award: The policy guide did not constitute a contract between the employer and its employees, and thus the employer did not breach a contract by denying the worker’s claim for short-term disability benefits that were listed in the policy guide, the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona ruled March 17 (Wilkes v. Elec. Data Sys. Corp., D. Ariz., No. CIV 04-341 TUC JMR, 3/17/06).
Discussion: The court found the policy guide’s disclaimer was clear and unambiguous and the employee could not have had a reasonable expectation that it constituted a commitment by the employer.
The court noted that the employee argued she was told by her supervisor that she did not have to read the policy guide because the supervisor would file her claims. If she did not read the plan, she could not have developed any expectations about the plan, the court said. If she did read the policy guide, she would have known that the employer did not intend to make a commitment to her, it said.
Pointers: The inclusion of disclaimers in employee policy guides and policy manuals can help employers avoid potential legal problems.
To prevent unintended limitations of employer discretion and authority, employee policy guides should include a general provision on the reservation of management rights. Such a provision might state that the company retains all rights and prerogatives conferred on employers and include examples, such as the right to take whatever actions are deemed necessary to achieve organizational goals and the right to set productivity and performance standards. In addition, the provision can state that any failure to exercise a particular right does not constitute a waiver of the right or preclude the company from exercising it in the future.
Employers commonly include a disclaimer against the creation of an implied contract, clarifying that policy guides do not override the at-will employment relationship. For example, the disclaimer might state that employees have the right to end their employment at any time for any reason, and the company reserves the right to do the same.
Another common disclaimer allows for employer discretion in making revisions to employee policy guides. Such a disclaimer should state that the company retains the right to modify or discontinue any policies, programs, or procedures described in the publications unless doing so would conflict with the terms of some other express agreement.
When employee policy guides include descriptions of employee benefits, employers should consider including a disclaimer stating that the descriptions are not intended to be complete. The disclaimer can inform employees that benefit plan details are contained in separate documents, and those documents take precedence over any conflicting information in the policy guide.
———————————————————————————————————–
It is our goal for every client to have their own customized policy guide. In order to assist clients with the building an implementation of a customized policy guide we provide a comprehensive document that can be edited to fit the needs, culture, procedures, etc. of individual clients. If you can’t locate the copy that we presented when first becoming associated with A Plus Benefits, please contact me or your assigned HR Advisor and we’ll e-mail you an electronic copy or send you a copy on disc, which ever you prefer.
It’s important for every organization to have a policy guide, why take the risk of having a judge tell you how you are going to run your business if you don’t have one? Further, it’s more efficient to decide how many situations will be handled before becoming embroiled with the problem. Deciding how to handle a touchy situation in the heat of the moment can often lead to unwise decisions.
Need some help with a policy guide? Please let us know. If we can help you implement a comprehensive policy guide now our goal of ……allowing you to get back to business….will be accomplished.
A Plus Benefits, Inc. appreciates your business – thank you!
Randall Barker is the VP of Human Resources for A Plus Benefits, Inc.
Read Randall’s previous HR Update.